一只狂暴化马猴烧酒。


我有一个脑洞,所有平行宇宙都不足以填补。空虚和寂寥时,它会突然吐露一言半语,有时是长篇大论。有的可爱,有的可怕,有的可笑,更多的,是不可言说。

【抛砖引玉/预告/草稿】跟Julystorms讨论团韩/干部组关系

 这不是正式分析,这是讨论草稿。今天有幸在tumblr上跟julystorms姑娘一起讨论了团韩headcanon,虽然我跟她的想法有一定分歧(悄悄说一句,我觉得我的脑补比她的更丰富详细和靠谱),但讨论让我受益匪浅(所以也请大家踊跃发言哦)。

本文作为分析团韩关系的草稿/预告。谈团韩关系,绕不开两个人的历史渊源。之前桔梗姑娘提起一件事,那就是韩吉从来不喊埃尔文“团长”,从来都以“埃尔文”称呼。就连利威尔都时不时的称埃尔文为“团长”。

我之前一直跟大部分团兵粉一样认为跟埃尔文关系最近的人是利威尔,以至于忽略了其实也至关重要的团韩关系。我觉得韩吉对埃尔文的了解/认识,可能甚至比利威尔还要多...(注意,这不代表团韩关系就近)。我知道这个说法听起来非常诡异,但我手里真的有一些证据,和很多站得住脚的脑补。

到今天为止,我对埃尔文这个人的认识一直在变。反反复复拼凑了许久,我认为埃尔文的核心特质是“detached”。他是个疏离的人,他疏离于队友,甚至疏离于自己。他逼着自己成为一个恶魔、成为一个让战友送命的人。他用“detachment”作为心理防御机制来保护自己痛苦的心。

然后我认为跟埃尔文关系最早最近的人还有米克。在埃尔文的尸堆上,米克最最顶端,而且还意义不明的冲着他暧昧微笑。

以上一些胡言乱语,算是food for thoughts,在我写出完整团韩关系前,本文作为笔记备忘。大家凑合看吧。

以下是我跟julystorms的聊天记录。我英文渣,各种低级语法错误,不过不妨碍理解大义,大家凑合看了... 核心信息等我正式写团韩关系时再提取。


cinocheese

I am!

May have an  ask for you? I suddenly realize that Hange always addresses Erewin simply as "Erewin"

no title, no "commander" things


cinocheese

And it seems that in OAD 1, her manners are even bold. It is very unusual in Japanese culture. I think the only explanation is that they have known each other for sooo long and they really are "equal" like friends

Do you think they could have been romantically involved? Thank you!


julystorms

Due to both of their natures being kind of...focused on achieving goals, I doubt they were romantically involved. I *do* think they are friendly, however. If we guess and say Hange is 30 years old, she's had more than a decade of experience working near/around Erwin, so it makes sense she'd call him by name. (And Hange does have a bold personality, so she's more likely to forego manners and speak what she's comfortable with saying.)


To compare, Nanaba may have been around as long as Hange has, but I don't think she calls Erwin by his first name. She's probably not comfortable enough around Erwin to do that--and not a close friend.


Hange, however, is a closer friend of Erwin (second only to Levi I think), so it makes sense for her to call him by name.


I like the pairing (erwin/hange) but I don't really think they've had any romantic involvement.


cinocheese

Thank you for your answer!! Hange's personality is bold but she still gives respect in the title. When she addresses Keith, her former commander, she respectfully referred to him as "Commander Keith" before she corrected it as "instructor Keith", though followed by very bold criticism on him. She used to admire Keith very much (now she is reluctant to admit that).



julystorms

Yeah, I wish we had more background about Hange and what her earlier years in the Survey Corps were like--especially her relationships to other soldiers. 


Unfortunately I don't think Isayama plans to focus very much on Hange, at least not yet.


cinocheese

I agree that they are less likely to be romantically involved - I personally believe that it is very difficult to get "close" with Erewin and Hange knows that... In fact, even Levi, the closest person to Erewin, is not that "close" to him. Maybe it is the nature of a commander; maybe Erewin is heart is so determined about his dreams/curiosity that he forced himself to be detached from everyone, including himself.



julystorms

I think you're right about Erwin! He kind of closes himself off from other people, and he focuses on other things because he knows a day will come when he might have to put his personal goals above his friends. So it's probably both things. Being commander is difficult work and to balance the responsibilities along with even casual friendships isn't easy.


I want more Hange background soo much!


评论(6)
热度(11)
©Kinokis | Powered by LOFTER